| Platinum | Slice of Heaven Bakery & Cafe |
| Gold | Pure Bliss Desserts |
| Silver | Mallard Ice Cream |
| Bronze | D'anna's Cafe Italiano |
| Top Pick | AB Crepes |
| Top Pick | Barb's Pies and Pastries |
| Top Pick | It's The Sweet Things |
| Top Pick | Lafeen's Family Pride Donuts and Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Sirena Gelato Shop |
| Top Pick | Sweet Haven |