| Platinum | Pirate Pies and Subs |
| Gold | Old World Deli |
| Silver | Sandwich Odyssey |
| Bronze | Cheba Hut |
| Top Pick | Avenue Bread & Cafe |
| Top Pick | Coconut Kenny's |
| Top Pick | Colophon Cafe |
| Top Pick | Da Vinci's Classic Subs |
| Top Pick | Magdalena's Creperie |
| Top Pick | Mount Bakery Cafe |